Working Class Party Has Best Showing in its History

The Working Class Party received more votes by far in 2024 than ever before. It has been running in partisan elections in a few states starting in 2016. It abstains from statewide races (except for Michigan statewide educational elections, and one run for Maryland Governor), and generally concentrates on U.S. House races and a smaller number of legislative races.

It has only run candidates in California, Illinois, Maryland, and especially Michigan.

In 2024, it polled 123,788 votes for U.S. House, even though it only had 9 candidates. In California, it was lucky enough to run Juan Rey in a district in which no Republican filed to be on the ballot, the 37th district. In the top-two primary, the only candidates on the ballot were two Democrats, one Peace & Freedom candidate, and the Working Class candidate. The Working Class candidate placed second in the primary and polled 44,450 votes in the two-person general election.

In Michigan in 2024, where the party has been running U.S. House candidates starting in 2016, it polled its highest U.S. House vote ever, 68,634 votes. It ran seven candidates. All seven districts also had a Democrat and a Republican in the race.

In Illinois in 2024, it ran one candidate who polled 10,704 votes in a race with both a Democrat and a Republican. Edward Hershey polled 5.19%, just enough to give the party qualified status in that one district, the Fourth District.

The party also polled its highest vote total ever for a statewide Michigan educational post. Mary Anne Hering polled 234,584 votes for State Board of Education, a higher vote total than any other minor party received in 2024 in any of the educational elections.

The party was qualified in Maryland in 2022, but did not poll enough votes to stay on, and was not on the ballot in 2024.

Libertarian City Councilmember Wins Lawsuit Against Oxnard, California’s Campaign Contribution Limits

On December 20, Aaron Starr and his organization won a lawsuit against the city of Oxnard’s limits on campaign contributions for city council candidates. Moving Oxnard Forward v Ascension, 21-56295. Here is the 2-1 decision, which was written by Judge Daniel P. Collins, a Trump appointee. The decision is also signed by visiting U.S. District Court Judge Stephen Joseph Murphy, a Bush Jr. appointee. The dissent is by Judge Mark J. Bennett, a Trump appointee.

The majority included in the opinion the evidence that the City Council put the campaign finance limits on the ballot (the voters passed it) just to stop Aaron Starr. It mentions that the city’s website, describing the measure, even put up references to Starr.

Starr was elected to the city council last month. He has been a California Libertarian Party activist for many years.

New Jersey Bill to Increase Petition Requirements Passes Assembly and Also Passes State Senate Committee

Identical bills have been introduced in the New Jersey legislature to increase the petition requirements for both primary and general elections. SB 3994 and AB 5117 increase the general election statewide petition from 800 signatures to 2,000. For U.S. House, the increase is from 100 to 250 signatures.

For primaries, statewide petitions rise from 1,000 to 2,500 signatures. U.S. House rises from 200 to 500. Legislature rises from 100 to 250.

AB 5117 was introduced December 9, and passed the Assembly on December 19 by a vote of 46-27. SB 3994 passed the Senate State Government Committee on December 19. Thanks to Deirdre Goldfarb for this news.

New York Ballot Access Lawsuit Reaches U.S. Supreme Court

On December 20, opponents of the New York May petition deadline for independent candidates filed a cert petition in the U.S. Supreme Court. Meadors v Erie County Board of Elections, number not yet assigned.

The U.S. District Court upheld the May deadline, which had been moved to May in 2019. Earlier the deadline had been in August.

The Second Circuit refused to hear the merits of the case, claiming the case was moot. The appeal to the U.S. Supreme Court is mainly concerned with the mootness issue. Back in 1968 the U.S. Supreme Court had said constitutional ballot access cases are not moot just because the election is over. The Second Circuit opinion is inconsistent with the 1968 precedent.

Libertarian U.S. Senate Candidates Polled Over 1,000,000 Votes

At the November 5 election, Libertarian candidates for U.S. Senate received 1,025,765 votes. This is not the first time the party’s candidates for U.S. Senate have topped one million. It also happened in 1992, 2000, 2016, and 2020.

The 2024 total includes the Wisconsin vote for Philip Norman Anderson, the Libertarian whose ballot label was “Disrupt the Corruption”, not “Libertarian.” He held himself out as the Libertarian nominee, and was simultaneously a Libertarian Party nominee for presidential elector, as well as recent past state party chair. See this newspaper story about his campaign. He polled 42,315 votes.